Traditional vs Roth Retirement Account, Which Is Better?

What is the difference between a traditional account and a Roth account? Which one is better for you? Which one should you invest in? Several factors can affect your decision. I will help you explore concepts to think about to assist when making that decision.

The main difference between a traditional account and a Roth account is the timing of when you pay taxes on the money. When you make a contribution to a traditional account you normally would be able to deduct that amount from your taxable income, which would reduce your taxable income the year you make the contribution. Then at retirement when you withdraw the money, you would pay taxes on the contributions and growth of the account. This is called tax-deferred money since you are deferring the taxes until later 

A Roth account works the opposite way. You do not reduce your taxable income the year you contribute the money, but then when you withdraw the money you do not have to pay taxes since you already paid them on the money contributed. This is called tax-free money since it is tax-free upon withdrawal.

Income Tax Brackets

One of the first things you will want to figure out is what federal income tax bracket you will be in for the current tax year. This is an important part of your decision when deciding if you should contribute to a traditional or a Roth account. Here are the federal income tax brackets for 2023. (Source: Voya 2023; link below)

If you are in one of the higher income tax brackets (32%, 35%, or 37%) it may make sense to contribute to a traditional instead of a Roth account since you would save more now on taxes than you would if you were in one of the lower income tax brackets (12%, 22%, 24%). If you think you are in a higher tax bracket now and will be in a lower tax bracket at retirement then it may make sense to contribute to a traditional instead of a Roth account. Keep in mind that politicians have adjusted the tax brackets many times in the past and will probably adjust them again before you reach retirement.

Time Horizon

Time until retirement is another factor to consider when making your decision. Generally, someone who is younger will have a lot more time for their money to earn compound interest and could be better off contributing to a Roth account. This way all of the principal & compound interest they withdraw at retirement would be tax-free, whereas if it was in a traditional account you would owe taxes on that money instead. My brother explains it as “would you rather pay taxes on the seeds or pay taxes on the entire tree once it is fully grown.” 

You might be someone who would rather lock in their tax rate now and not have to worry about if it will be higher or lower at retirement. If you are that type of person then you will want to consider contributing to a Roth account. If you are someone who believes your tax rate at retirement will be lower than what it is currently, then you will want to consider contributing to a traditional account.

Required Minimum Distributions

Required Minimum Distributions (RMDs) are another reason why you might decide to contribute to a Roth instead of a traditional account. After a certain age (as of 2022 it is 72) the government requires that you withdraw a specified amount of money every year from your accounts as they want to get their tax money back on that tax-deferred money. If you have that money in a Roth IRA then there are no RMDs, unless it is an inherited Roth IRA. (Source; Fidelity; link below)

Employer Plans

If you participate in a retirement plan at work, most companies offer some type of matching program. If you contribute a certain amount they will contribute a match. Dollar on the dollar or fifty cents on the dollar up to a certain amount appears to be the most common matching contributions. More employers are now offering a Roth option. If you elect to have your contributions go toward the Roth bucket be aware that your employer will more than likely contribute their match into the traditional bucket, so they are able to receive the tax deduction. This may be a good thing as it could help you diversify your risk by having some money tax-deferred and some money tax-free at retirement.

If you are a participant in an employer-sponsored retirement plan at work then there is a deductibility phase-out for IRA’s if your modified adjusted gross income (MAGI) is above a certain amount. In other words, you wouldn’t get the tax deduction by contributing to a traditional IRA plan if your income is over a certain amount and you have a retirement plan at work. For Roth IRA’s there is a phase-out limit. As your MAGI increases, the amount the IRS allows you to contribute decreases until you are no longer allowed to contribute. Refer to the Voya 2022 Quick Tax Reference Guide if you are curious as to the specific ranges. (Source: Voya 2023; link below)

If you have more questions about if you should contribute to a Roth or a traditional account feel free to set up a meeting with me as I am happy to discuss strategies personalized to your situation. If you are looking for the best of both traditional and Roth accounts then click here to learn more about how Health Savings Accounts can be used as a stealth retirement account.

Sources: https://www.kiplinger.com/retirement/retirement-plans/roth-iras

https://individuals.voya.com/document/tax-center/2023-quick-tax-reference.pdf

https://www.fidelity.com/building-savings/learn-about-iras/required-minimum-distributions/overview

Fiduciary Financial Advisors, LLC is a registered investment adviser and does not give legal or tax advice. Information presented is for educational purposes only and does not intend to make an offer or solicitation for the sale or purchase of any securities. The information contained herein has been obtained from a third party source which is believed to be reliable but is subject to correction for error. Investments involve risk and are not guaranteed. Past performance is not a guarantee or representation of future results.